2

Don't blame "the press" for what happened at News of the World

Posted by David Simister on Friday, July 08, 2011 in , , ,

ONE OF the first rules of journalism: take any time off and you just know something dramatic is going to happen.

What I couldn't have imagined, as I sat on a windy campsite in Cornwall, was that this week's big news was the news itself. The News of The World has been axed after a series of increasingly outrageous allegations of phone hacking. David Cameron's former press chief has been arrested. Media pundits, as my colleague David Raven has already pointed out, are putting the smart money on a Sun on Sunday being launched to fill the gap. All this while I was trying not to be sick on the Isles of Scilly ferry.

But what bothers me most is where the blame's now being pointed by the politicians; the Press Complaints Commission, which all three of the main party leaders are now saying should be scrapped. Labour leader Ed Milliband - a man who, judging by a certain interview he gave last week, isn't all that media-savvy anyway - has called it "a toothless poodle", while the PCC itself has put its foot in it and used the NOTW scandal as a catchall for slating the entire newspaper industry, calling it "a terrible time for British journalism".

I agree partly; it is a terrible time for British journalism, but not because of what News International are doing. It's a terrible time because all three of the major political parties have clearly gone mad, using the (alleged) failings of one national tabloid as an excuse to call for the PCC to be scrapped, on the basis that journalists sit on its board, and journalists are all nasty people who'd sell their own mothers for a good story. A new body, free of those pesky journalist types, should be set up to take its place.

This, I honestly reckon, is giving the entire class detention because one boy kicked a football through the school window, and it's not fair on the thousands of journalists - journalists like me, incidentally - who can do their jobs without resorting to hacking people's phone lines. Any kneejerk reactions to "the press" because of what happened at News of the World will have a knock-on effect for every newspaper, including The Champion. Scrapping the PCC will affect every title, regional or national, up and down the land.

I'll leave the last line to Society of Editors chief Bob Satchwell, a lone voice of media sanity in these troubled times.

"The idea that this is a total failure of ethics across the press and of the PCC is absolute nonsense."

|

2 Comments

Anonymous says:

But in what way has the PCC ever been effective? Even when it totally upholds a complaint and issues a rebuke in the strongest possible terms - such as the Standard's completely false allegations about Climate Camp protesters at Heathrow planning to leave hoax bombs in the airport - there's no penalty for the offender.

A few stern words and an ambiguously worded apology buried deep in the paper compared to thousands more papers sold? Price well worth paying for the paper. When the PCC throw the book at you it's one of those little books of kittens they sell next to the till in Waterstones.

It's alright if you're Elton John and can afford the kickass lawyer to sue The Sun for writing lies and get a million quid in compensation. But if you're one of the thousands of ordinary people savaged by tabloids you've got no real comeback.

As anyone who's ever found themselves at the fridge at midnight knows, self regulation doesn't work. A proper independent commission with power of sanction is clearly needed.

Do you have a problem with that?


Thanks for your comment and for raising some interesting points.

I've no problem at all with the PCC being given a sharper set of teeth so that it can take tougher action against those who breach its code of conduct, but my worry is that the calls to abolish it altogether are a kneejerk reaction to one newspaper's actions which will potentially affect every title in the country, whether they're regional or national.

I think that journalists who know how the industry works have an important role to play in the PCC, but it's never been to the extent that it's "self regulation".

As the PCC itself says:

"There are seventeen members of the Press Complaints Commission. A majority of them have no connection with the press - ensuring that the PCC is independent of the newspaper industry."

Post a Comment

Copyright © 2009 Simantics All rights reserved. Theme by Laptop Geek. | Bloggerized by FalconHive.